11 Pumpkin Flavored Treats In Columbus For The Fall Obsessed

Originally published 10/6/17. Updated 10/2/19.

Everyone loves pumpkin. Or at least, they do in my mind.

It’s probably because I’ve been obsessed with pumpkin for a long time. You know, before it was cool– a pumpkin hipster, if you will. Of course, you can quench your thirst for all things pumpkin at the grocery store or Starbucks. But if you’re looking to take your favorite fall habit to the next level, you’ve come to the right girl.

Here are the 11 pumpkin-flavored treats to bring out the #basic in all of us.

Pumpkin Cream Puff from Schmidt’s
An autumn twist on a classic, Columbus dessert.


Pumpkin Pie Ice Cream from Simply Rolled
The holy trifecta: Pumpkin. Pie. Ice Cream.


Pumpkin Pecan Profiterole Pistacia Vera
A pumpkin treat so light and airy, you won’t feel guilty about going back for seconds.


Pumpkin Spice Whoopie Pie from Pattycake Bakery
100% vegan. 100% delicious.


Pumpkin Chocolate Chip Bars from Cherbourg Bakery
The perfect snack to share with friends or coworkers who are just as pumpkin-obsessed as you are.


Pumpkin Roll Donuts from Buckeye Donuts
My favorite donuts in Columbus made with my favorite flavor. Yum.


Pumpkin Pie Ice Cream from Graeter’s
Grab a pint, throw on a comfy sweater, and curl up. I know this is the second pumpkin pie ice cream on the list, but can you ever really have too many options?


Pumpkin Pie from Just Pies
For when you’re craving the OG pumpkin dessert.


Pumpkin Spice Cheesecake from Chocolate Cafe
Everything you love about cheesecake, plus pumpkin.


Pumpkin Spice Bundt Cake from Nothing Bundt Cake
These little pumpkin cakes pack a punch. They are flavorful and filling and completely wonderful in every way.


Pumpkin Chai from Stauf’s
Don’t be one of those girls who goes on and on about a PSL. Get a Pumpkin Chai instead.