Skip to content Skip to sidebar Skip to footer

Where To Find The Best New York Style Pizza In Columbus

There’s shortage of delicious pizzerias in Columbus.

You can find just about every kind of pizza in C-bus too, from our very own Columbus style to Detroit style and everything in between. But on those days when you’re craving a massive piece of pizza that you can fold perfectly in half, only New York style pizza will do.

Luckily, there are some pizza joints around town that take their commitment to delicious New York Style pizza very, very seriously. Spoiler alert: this may (will definitely) make you hungry.

Pizzeria New York

via Facebook

Pizzeria New York has been serving up authentic NY pizza for nearly two decades. The owner brought family recipes from Queens, NY to create delicious pizza in Pickerington. In addition to pizza, Pizzeria New York also serves salads, stromboli, calzones, and more. There are two locations, one in Blacklick and one in Pickerington. To see their hours, please click here.
Website: Pizzeria New York

Borgata Pizza

via Facebook

Borgata Pizza uses high-quality local and regional ingredients to create authentic New York style pizza. All of the pasta, pizza dough, sauces, house specialties, vinaigrette salad dressings, and desserts are made in-house, from scratch. Borgata has two brick-and-mortar locations, or you can swing by Budd Dairy Food Hall.
Website: Borgata Pizza

Brooklyn Pizza

via Facebook

Brooklyn Pizza in Powell is a family-owned business that claims to be Powell’s only authentic New York style pizza joint. It is certainly a favorite spot for NYC transplants looking for a slice of home, which is saying something. You can find Brooklyn Pizza at 240 North Liberty St., Powell, OH 43065.
Website: Brooklyn Pizza

Aracri Pizzeria

via Facebook

Before it was Aracri Pizzeria, it was called Cafe Napolitana. The pizzeria was opened downtown back in 1992 by Italian immigrant Palmo Aracri and his wife Deanne. The pizza at Aracri Pizzeria is made using an authentic Italian dough and the menu includes other Italian favs like Chicken Parmigiana and Baked Cheese Arrabiata. You’ll find the shop at 51 E Gay St, Columbus, OH 43215.
Website: Aracri Pizzeria

East Coast Pizzeria

via Facebook

East Coast Pizzeria is hand-tossed and brick-fired exactly as it should be: to a delicious golden crust topped with real, high-quality mozzarella and other fresh toppings. In addition to amazing NY-style pizza, the pizzeria also serves flatbreads, strombolis, calzones, salads, desserts, and more. East Coast Pizzeria is located at 5060 North High St, Columbus, OH 43214.
Website: East Coast Pizzeria

Papa Giorgio’s

via Facebook

With locally-sourced ingredients and a dough recipe straight from a master baker in Italy, you can never go wrong when ordering Papa Giorgio’s. The pizza is affordable, delicious, and the perfect folding treat to enjoy at the end of any stressful day. Papa Giorgio’s has two locations, one in Clintonville and one off of Bethel Rd. You can view both locations here.
Website: Papa Giorgio’s

Sarefino’s Pizzeria & Italian Deli

new york style pepperoni pizza pie
via Facebook

Sarefino’s is a great spot for lunch. Located within the North Market downtown, the pies at this authentic NY-style spot are hand tossed and served in the iconic pie shape every single day. Favorites include pepperoni, cheese, and a mouthwatering veggie pizza with spinach, artichokes, and roasted red peppers. Sarefino’s is located at 59 West Spruce Street
Columbus, Ohio 43215.
Website: Sarefino’s Pizzeria & Italian Deli