We sifted through the reviews, the grease-stained wrappers, and the endless “best burger” debates to bring you this: 10 top-rated burger joints around Columbus, straight from Yelp reviews (and a lot of loyal fans).
The list runs from no-frills to a little fancy. Here’s where to go next.
Each rating and review count here comes straight from the restaurant’s Yelp page, checked November 1, 2026. The list counts down to the highest rating, and when two spots tie, the one with more reviews ranks higher.
10. Danny’s Delicious Deli
Yelp rating: 4.0/5 (104 reviews)
Where: 37 W. Broad St.
Why locals love it: Danny’s is a downtown deli, and the burger is the sleeper on the menu. This no-frills deli churns out thick, juicy burgers that taste like they came off your backyard grill, if your uncle was a burger whisperer. The catch is the hours, Monday through Friday from 8 a.m. to 2 p.m.
9. Johnnie’s Tavern
Yelp rating: 4.0/5 (169 reviews)
Where: 3503 Trabue Rd.
Why locals love it: Johnnie’s is a west side dive bar, and it looks the part. Their burgers are big, greasy, and come with all the dive bar charm you’d hope for.
8. Preston’s: A Burger Joint
Yelp rating: 4.0/5 (247 reviews)
Where: 2973 N. High St.
Why locals love it: These are the burgers your foodie friends won’t shut up about. Preston’s does burgers that are messy and rich, the kind you need extra napkins for. Preston’s also runs a second counter inside The Little Grand Market.
7. The Old Mohawk
Yelp rating: 4.0/5 (469 reviews)
Where: 819 Mohawk St.
Why locals love it: The Old Mohawk is a historic German Village spot, and the cozy room gets most of the attention. Their burgers are legit, especially when paired with one of their famous soups. It’s a comfort food power combo.
6. Harvest Pizzeria Bexley
Yelp rating: 4.1/5 (151 reviews)
Where: 2376 E. Main St., Bexley
Why locals love it: You might come for the wood-fired pizza, but don’t sleep on the burger. It’s stacked, saucy, and just upscale enough to make you feel a little fancy about it.
5. O’Reilly’s Pub
Yelp rating: 4.1/5 (180 reviews)
Where: 2822 N. High St.
Why locals love it: O’Reilly’s is an Irish pub on High Street, and the burger has a following of its own. The menu keeps it classic and comforting, with a burger that hits just right after a pint or two.
4. Harvest Pizzeria Dublin
Yelp rating: 4.1/5 (238 reviews)
Where: 45 N. High St., Dublin
Why locals love it: Harvest built its name on wood-fired pizza, but the burger here has fans too. The ingredients are top-notch, and the flavor is dialed in. Don’t skip it.
3. Ringside Cafe
Yelp rating: 4.3/5 (210 reviews)
Where: 19 N. Pearl St.
Why locals love it: Old-school boxing memorabilia meets knockout burgers. This downtown classic has been slinging patties forever, and they’ve only gotten better with age. The Buster Douglas is a pound and a half of burger.
2. Harvest Pizzeria Clintonville
Yelp rating: 4.3/5 (539 reviews)
Where: 2885 N. High St.
Why locals love it: This Clintonville staple leans seasonal and local, and their burger is no exception. Every bite feels curated and satisfying without being too precious. On Yelp, you’ll still find it under the old name, Harvest Bar + Kitchen.
1. HangOverEasy
Yelp rating: 4.4/5 (382 reviews)
Where: 51 Parsons Ave.
Why locals love it: A true greasy spoon, HangOverEasy is breakfast-meets-burger heaven. The burgers are big, bold, and perfect for those I-need-to-eat-something-amazing-immediately moods. The HOE Burger puts a fried egg on top of Boursin and red onion marmalade.
More Burgers Yelp Rates Highly
Yelp’s own burger search puts three more spots near the top right now. Smash Buddies sits at 4.7/5 (56 reviews). Stacked Burger Co. rates even higher at 4.8/5 (90 reviews), and Arch City Tavern has piled up 4.3/5 (644 reviews). All three have entries in the full guide to the best burgers in Columbus.
