I’m sorry to be the bearer of bad news, but fans of Krema Nut Company’s beloved sandwiches and milkshakes are in for a disappointment.
After careful consideration, the company has decided to permanently discontinue these menu items, marking the official end of an era for Krema’s lunch counter, which has served up tasty bites and creamy shakes since 2004.
In a social media post, the company explained that as its retail and mail-order business has grown.
But so have the demands on its small staff and limited space. With this expansion, it’s become necessary for Krema to reassess how its retail area is used to best serve the evolving needs of its business and customers.
As much as we’ll miss those fresh sandwiches and signature shakes, it’s important to remember that Krema Nut Co. is still the go-to spot for all things nuts and gifting. Whether you’re shopping for a gift or picking up your favorite snack, Krema will continue to be a staple in the community.
Since November 4, the sandwich and milkshake counter has been closed for the holiday season, so this announcement just marks the official end of these offerings moving forward. The company mentioned that opening and closing the counter around the holidays was simply not feasible given logistics and staffing challenges.
For those mourning the loss of the Buckeye milkshake, there is a glimmer of hope.
Krema Nut Co. shared that it’s working on a partnership with Johnson’s Real Ice Cream to offer the iconic Buckeye and Peanut Butter shakes at their shop. Until then, though, Krema’s got a simple hack to recreate the magic at home: mix vanilla ice cream, chocolate sauce, and peanut butter sauce to whip up your very own Buckeye shake.
Krema Nut Co. has been a fixture in Grandview Heights since 1927, with the sandwich counter addition in 2004. While it’s sad to see this chapter close, the company’s long history of providing quality nuts and snacks will continue to delight customers for years to come.
To see what kind of products Krema Nut Co. is offering, head over to krema.com.
