11 Holiday Treats From Local Bakeries For The Sweet Obsessed

Baking yummy treats for the holidays can be a fun and rewarding tradition for the whole family.

But if you’re terrible at baking, much like myself, you’d probably rather skip the dirty dishes and buy a delicious dessert instead. Of course, Columbus has your back. Let’s be honest though. Would you expect anything less from this food-obsessed city?

I hope you’re ready to gobble up some desserts. Here are the 11 best holiday treats waiting to be enjoyed by you and your family this December.


Pfeffernusse Cream Puff from Schmidt’s

There’s no such thing as a bad cream puff from Schmidt’s. The Pfeffernusse Cream Puff is no exception. Based on a family recipe for German spice Christmas cookies, this delightful dessert will have you coming back for more.


Hot Cocoa Ice Cream from Simply Rolled

Why hasn’t hot chocolate always been served in ice cream form? Seriously, this changes everything.


Chocolate Truffles from Pistacia Vera

If you’re invited to any holiday parties this season, show up with some Chocolate Truffles from Pistacia Vera. You will instantly become everyone’s favorite person at the party.


Gingerbread Cookies from Pattycake Bakery

Keep it old school with these gingerbread cookies. Plus, they’re not just tasty. They’re also adorable.

View this post on Instagram

Let’s get festive, y’all!

A post shared by pattycakebakery (@pattycakebakery) on


Eggnog Donut from Cherbourg Bakery

Looking for a doughy overload? Ditch the calorie counter and grab a eggnog donut. You can thank me later.

View this post on Instagram

Egg nog donuts have hatched 🐣

A post shared by Cherbourg Bakery (@cherbourgbakery) on


Sugar Plum Scones from Kittie’s Cakes

These sugar plums may not be dancing, but they will certainly be stuck in your head once you’ve tried one.


Christmas Donuts from Peace, Love and Little Donuts

I know what you’re thinking… “more donuts?” Yes. More donuts. Life always needs more donuts.


Peppermint Chip Wheelies from Graeter’s Ice Cream

Part cookie, part ice cream, wholly delightful.


Sugar Cookies from Chocolate Cafe

You can’t have Christmas without some old fashioned sugar cookies. It’s a law… that I just made up.

View this post on Instagram

Dear Santa, We're ready for you. Love, The Chocolate Cafe

A post shared by Chocolate Cafe (@chocolatecafecolumbus) on


Snickerdoodle Bundt Cake from Nothing Bundt Cakes

Is there anything that comes out of Nothing Bundt Cakes that’s not perfection? Spoiler alert: No. Everything they make is perfect, including this snickerdoodle bundt cake.


Christmas Tree Cakes from Bake Me Happy

They’re Christmas tree cakes and they’re baked with literal happiness. What more do you need to know?


Happy Holidays! Enjoy all of your desserts before New Year’s guilt sets in. Oh- Don’t forget to save some for Santa!

A daily Columbus email you'll actually love.

A daily Columbus email you'll actually love.

Every morning we compile the best of Columbus news & events and deliver it in a quick 5 minute read that sets you up with everything you need to be a well informed Columbusian. Columbusite. Cbussian? Whatever, give it a try, you'll love it.

You have Successfully Subscribed!

Scroll to Top