The 10 Best Places For Chocolate Buckeye Lovers Around Ohio

Peanut butter and chocolate go together almost as well as our favorite colors scarlet and gray.

Buckeye candies are a favorite treat for nearly every Ohio heart.  Dipping peanut butter balls in melted chocolate is a popular holiday tradition in Ohio.  Making hundreds of buckeye candies with my grandma will always be a delicious memory of my childhood. Trays and trays would fill the counter tops and tables before we slid them in the freezer until morning. But when it’s not the holiday season and grandma’s not around, these 10 places are sure to meet all your buckeye needs.

Anthony Thomas 

via the Anthony Thomas website

Address: 4636 West Broad St. Columbus, Ohio 43228
Multiple locations.

Eagle Family Candy

via Facebook
Address: 4590 N High St. Columbus, OH 43214

Marie’s Candies

via the Maries Candies website

Address: 311 Zanesfield Rd. West Liberty, Ohio 43357

Buckeye Chocolate Company

via the Buckeye Chocolate Company website

Address: 15065 Kinsman Rd. Middlefield, Ohio 44062

Sweet Tooth Cottage

via Facebook

Address: 10221 Sawmill Parkway Powell, OH 43065

Elevator Brewing Company

Address: 161 N. High St. Columbus, OH

Greater’s Ice Cream

via the Greaters website

Address: 1534 W. Lane Avenue, 43221
Multiple Locations.

Whits Frozen Custard

via Facebook

Address: 3339 North High St. Columbus, Ohio 43202
Multiple Locations.

Buckeye Donuts

via Facebook

Address: 1998 N High St, Columbus, OH 43201

Milo’s Catering Company

via Facebook

Address: 980 W Broad St. Columbus, OH 43222

Who’s ready to spoil dinner?


What’s your favorite place to fill your buckeye cravings? Tell us on Facebook and Twitter!