We love supporting new and existing restaurants around Columbus. It’s about so much more than food and drinks. Good restaurants offer a home away from home for regulars, a place to celebrate the highs and wish away the lows, and the opportunity to meet new people and make new friends.
But sadly, all good things must come to an end. We highlight new restaurants that are opening every month, but we also think that it’s important to let people know when local spots close.
Get ready to say goodbye to some of the delicious eateries that have closed here in Columbus over the past month.
Nada
After more than a decade in the Arena District, Cincinnati-based Mexican eatery Nada quietly closed its Columbus location at 220 W. Nationwide Blvd. late last month.
There was no formal public announcement, but the signs were clear: the Columbus location disappeared from Nada’s website, and a “Permanently Closed” notice appeared on the restaurant’s doors.
The spot was known for its upscale take on tacos, margaritas, and vibrant dining space — and while the closure is disappointing, Nada continues to operate in other cities.
The Hickory House (Gahanna)
A Gahanna favorite known for its ribs and rustic charm has closed its doors for good. The Hickory House at 550 Officenter Pl. shared the news via a message on its website, confirming the permanent closure.
The family-owned restaurant had been serving up barbecue classics since 1979, with the Gahanna location opening in 2003. Famous for two-pound baby back ribs and a housemade BBQ sauce, Hickory House leaves behind a long legacy of neighborhood comfort food.
A Blessed Cookie Co.
After nearly 30 years in the Arena District, A Blessed Cookie Co. has officially closed its storefront at 3 Nationwide Plaza.
The business, known for its old-school charm and delicious scratch-made cookies, cited the current financial climate as the reason for closing.
In a social media statement, owner Dee Tolber shared:
“The decision is bittersweet. We have enjoyed and will miss the daily interactions with you… [but] this decision will allow ABC to explore opportunities for increased future revenues.”
While the shop is closing and online sales are paused for now, the team has hinted that this isn’t the end. Stay tuned to their Instagram for what’s next.
Café Istanbul (Bexley)
Cafe Istanbul, a longtime favorite in Bexley for Turkish cuisine, has closed its doors after 13 years.
The restaurant, located at 2455 E. Main St., did not make a formal announcement, but city officials confirmed the closure. The Bexley location’s website is no longer active, though their affiliated restaurants at Easton and Dublin remain open.
Whether it was your go-to for lamb shank, baklava, or a special occasion dinner, Cafe Istanbul will be missed by many in the neighborhood.
Marino’s Seafood Fish & Chips
After 32 years on W. 5th Avenue, Marino’s Seafood Fish & Chips has served its last platter. The longtime local favorite announced it would be closing at the end of June.
Known for its no-frills, deep-fried comfort food and loyal neighborhood following, Marino’s closure is another blow for fans of Columbus’ old-school eateries. But it’s not all bad news. Arthur Treacher’s is coming back to the space, returning to Columbus years after their final shop closed here.
