Valentine’s Day means heart-shaped pizza.
There are a lot of ways to celebrate the most romantic day of the year. If a low-key celebration is more your speed, we’ve got a great suggestion for the dinner portion of the evening.
It’s pretty hard not to enjoy yourself when there’s pizza involved in any situation, and that’s especially true when it’s a holiday all about love and a pizza pie in the shape of a heart. Yes, it’s both figuratively and literally cheesy, but we don’t care. We’re all in on the heart-shaped pizza, friends.
There are plenty of places around Columbus where you can grab this Valentine’s Day special, and we’ve rounded them all up here for you!
Most of these places only make them for a few days around February 14, and a few run out. The details below are from last Valentine’s Day, so call ahead if you’re planning around them.
| Pizzeria | Where | When it ran last Valentine’s Day | What you get | How to order |
| Grandma’s Pizza on Parsons | 1242 Parsons Ave, Columbus | Around Valentine’s Day | Heart-shaped pizza | Call 614-449-0777 |
| Flyers Pizza | Ten central Ohio shops | Through Feb. 15 | One-topping heart-shaped pizza, $11.29, $2.50 goes to Autism Speaks Columbus | Online or call your store |
| Massey’s Pizza | A dozen shops around central Ohio | Around Valentine’s Day | Heart-shaped pizza, call and ask | Call your location |
| Joseppi’s Pizza | Four west side shops | Feb. 13 and 14 only | Heart-shaped pizza until they run out | Call or walk in |
| Donatos | Every Donatos | Feb. 6 to 15 | One-topping thin crust, priced as a medium, uncut | Online, app, phone, or in store |
| Mikey’s Late Night Slice | Ten shops around Columbus | Feb. 14, plus Mother’s Day | Any whole pizza made heart-shaped, no extra charge | Ask when you order |
| Borgata Pizza Cafe | 2285 W Dublin-Granville Rd, Worthington | Feb. 14 | 16- or 20-inch pie on request | Ask when you order |
| Luna Pizza Kitchen | Bethel Rd, Tuttle Crossing, Morse Rd | All of February | 12-inch heart-shaped pizza | Call or order online |
Grandma’s Pizza on Parsons
Grandma’s on Parsons did heart-shaped pizzas again in 2026. You have to call to order, and they post the dates and price on Facebook each year.
Where: 1242 Parsons Ave, Columbus
Phone: 614-449-0777
Website: Grandma’s Pizza on Parsons
Flyers Pizza
via Facebook
Flyers has done its Give a Pizz-a Your Heart fundraiser for more than ten years. Buy a one-topping heart-shaped pizza at any of its ten shops and $2.50 goes to Autism Speaks Columbus. In 2026 it was $11.29, a little bigger than a regular 11-inch, and it ran through February 15. You can order online or call.
Where: Ten shops from Powell to Grove City, full list here
Website: Flyers Pizza
Massey’s Pizza
via Facebook
Massey’s does a heart-shaped pizza around Valentine’s Day, but you have to call and ask for it. They have a dozen shops around central Ohio, from Powell down to Lancaster.
Where: Shops around central Ohio, full list here
Website: Massey’s Pizza
Joseppi’s Pizza
Joseppi’s has been on the west side since 1969. They only make the heart-shaped pizza on February 13 and 14, and when they run out, that’s it. There are four shops: Lincoln Village, the Hilltop, Grove City and Orient.
Where: 4764 W Broad St, Columbus, plus three more on the locations page
Website: Joseppi’s Pizza
Donatos
via Facebook
Donatos does heart-shaped pizzas every February. It’s a one-topping pizza on the thin crust and costs the same as a medium. It comes uncut so you don’t break the heart. In 2026 it ran February 6 through 15, and you can order online or on the phone.
Where: Every Donatos in central Ohio
Website: Donatos
Mikey’s Late Night Slice
Mikey’s will make any whole pizza heart-shaped on Valentine’s Day (and Mother’s Day) for no extra charge. Just ask when you order. They have ten shops around Columbus, so this is the easy one if you didn’t plan ahead.
Where: 1030 N High St, Short North, plus nine more on the locations page
Website: Mikey’s Late Night Slice
Borgata Pizza Cafe
Borgata in Worthington has made 16- and 20-inch heart-shaped pizzas on Valentine’s Day if you ask. Call ahead to make sure they’re doing it this year.
Where: 2285 W Dublin-Granville Rd, Worthington
Website: Borgata Pizza Cafe
Luna Pizza Kitchen
Luna has done a 12-inch heart-shaped pizza all of February at its Bethel Road, Tuttle Crossing and Morse Road shops. Call or order online.
Where: 2052 Crown Plaza Dr, Columbus; 5380 Tuttle Crossing Blvd, Dublin; 4238 Morse Rd, Columbus
Website: Luna Pizza Kitchen
The chains do it too
The big chains do heart-shaped pizzas too, usually for about a week around Valentine’s Day.
Papa Johns makes a thin-crust one-topping heart-shaped pizza starting at $11.99. It comes unsliced with a seasoning packet and a pepperoncini.
Pizza Hut has a medium one-topping heart-shaped pizza on hand-tossed crust starting at $11.99, uncut, for delivery or carryout. In 2026 they did it with the Backstreet Boys.
Marco’s Pizza had heart-shaped pizzas starting at $7.99 from February 12 to 14 in 2026, or $13.99 with a brownie. Order online or in the app.
Jet’s Pizza does heart-shaped pizzas on Valentine’s Day at its central Ohio stores.
Papa Murphy’s sells a take-and-bake HeartBaker, cheese or pepperoni, for $11, or $16 with cookie dough. In 2026 it ran February 1 to 14.
California Pizza Kitchen at Polaris will make any thin-crust pizza heart-shaped for free if you get the Valentine’s dinner for two, which was $60 and ran February 9 to 15 in 2026. Dine-in only.
Aldi sells a frozen heart-shaped pizza in February if you’d rather make it at home.
Can you get one any other time of year?
Not really. These places only do hearts around Valentine’s Day, and Mikey’s adds Mother’s Day. If you want one in July, call and ask, but don’t count on it.
Order ahead if you can. Joseppi’s only does it for two days and stops when they run out, and Donatos and Flyers both wrap up the day after Valentine’s Day.
