Skip to content Skip to sidebar Skip to footer

Stauf’s Coffee Roasters Wants To Take You To Church In Their New Neil Ave. Spot

As Hozier says, take me to church. Especially if that church has recently been remodeled into one of my favorite coffee shops in Columbus.

Stauf’s Coffee Roasters have opened yet another location in our fair city. I know that some of you are probably thinking, how exactly is that newsworthy? Well, let me tell you. This is the most unique coffee shop in the city.

Located at 1334 (not 1335 like Google Maps says) Neil Ave., the building used to be home to the Neil Avenue Presbyterian Church. Stauf’s has taken up residence in the former sanctuary, and they’ve got the vaulted ceilings and stained glass windows to prove it.

Historic stone church building housing Stauf's Coffee Roasters, with a crenellated tower

The building is owned by Legacy Management Services and it isn’t just home to Stauf’s. The rest of the church has been transformed into apartments.

In addition to the beautiful seating area inside of the coffee shop, there’s also a large patio out front. This place is definitely worth a visit, not only for the coffee but also for the Instagram opportunity. Don’t judge, it’s that awesome. Don’t believe me? Keep scrolling and you’ll see.

Historic stone church building that houses Stauf's Coffee Roasters, with outdoor patio seating

Chalkboard sign for Stauf's Coffee Roasters reading 'we're open' on a brick stairway

Historic interior of Stauf's Coffee Roasters with a wooden staircase and stained glass windows

Interior of Stauf's Coffee Roasters with exposed ductwork, stained glass windows, and a green sofa

Menu board listing coffee, espresso, and drink prices above a stained glass door

A bakery display counter features muffins, bagels, and a menu board listing Sammy's Bagels varieties

Coffee shop counter with a brew of the day sign and syrup menu board

Glowing turquoise neon sign with stylized letter S on white wall

Interior of Stauf's Coffee Roasters with tall stained glass windows and patrons on laptops

Outdoor patio at Stauf's Coffee Roasters with patrons seated near a dog

Stone church building housing Stauf's Coffee Roasters with outdoor seating on Neil Avenue

Chelsea Wiley

Written by

Chelsea Wiley

Chelsea Wiley, first of her name, Queen of the Seven Andals... wait. That's not right. Joking aside, Chelsea is a writer and photographer born and raised in Columbus, Ohio. She is an avid reader and a lover of animals.