Updated: July 30, 2026
Shopping at consignment stores is a great way to find high-quality clothes at affordable prices.
When it comes to consignment stores, most people have heard of Plato’s Closet, Clothes Mentor, and Once Upon A Child but Columbus has more shops that you might not have heard of.
Some of these shops focus on luxury consignment, offering sustainable and affordable ways to shop for your favorite high-end brands.
Ready to dive in? You never know what you might be able to find.
Second Chance Consignment Boutique
Second Chance has major boutique vibes. From designer brands to high-quality clothes and accessories, the atmosphere in Second Chance is bright and welcoming. The shop has been serving the Columbus area for over three decades and is always a reliable stop on a day of shopping.
Website: Second Chance Consignment Boutique
Location: 1803 W. Fifth Ave., Grandview Heights, OH 43212
One More Time
One More Time has carried women’s and men’s fashion on West 5th Avenue for more than 45 years, split across two shops a couple of blocks apart. One More Time has everything that shoppers could need when wanting to refresh their wardrobe on a budget. You’ll find plenty of amazing inspiration throughout the shop, so don’t worry if you don’t know exactly what you’re looking for when you head in.
Website: One More Time
Location: 1521 W 5th Ave, Columbus, OH 43212
Eclectic Fashion Alternatives
Eclectic Fashion is a men’s fashion consignment shop that has been a part of the Columbus consignment community for 30 years. It is one of the few consignment shops to carry men’s clothing, let alone specialize in it. From designer to vintage, it is a great place to get office-appropriate jackets, shirts, ties, pants, and more.
Website: Eclectic Fashion Alternatives
Location: 3139 N High St, Columbus, OH 43202
STORE 5a
STORE 5a is the resale arm of Diamond Cellar, and the cases read like it: Rolex, Cartier, Louis Vuitton, Hermes. The focus here is jewelry, watches, and designer handbags rather than clothing racks, and every piece gets authenticated in-house before it hits the floor. Shop it inside the Diamond Cellar stores on Sawmill Road in Dublin and at Easton.
Website: STORE 5a
Location: 6280 Sawmill Rd, Dublin, OH 43017 and 3960 New Bond St, Columbus, OH 43219
SoHo Luxury Exchange
SoHo Luxury Exchange is a luxury fashion and accessory consignment boutique that caters to men and women. SoHo specializes in designer and fashionable brands. The shop verifies all of their luxury goods, giving the shopper peace of mind that they’re getting the real deal on their favorite items.
Website: SoHo Luxury Exchange
Location: 32 E Olentangy St, Powell, OH 43065
Deja Vu
This women’s fashion consignment shop has been serving the Columbus community for over 40 years. It’s in Uptown Westerville and a short walk from Otterbein University’s campus. Need a blazer for that big job interview? Make sure to stop by Deja Vu.
Website: Deja Vu
Location: 11 N. State St, Westerville, Ohio 43081
Consignment shopping FAQ
How does consignment work?
You bring in clothes or accessories, the shop sells them for you, and you get a cut of the sale price once the piece sells. Each shop sets its own split and drop-off rules, so check before you load up the car.
What’s the difference between a consignment shop and a thrift store?
Thrift stores sell donated goods, so prices are low and the racks are a grab bag. Consignment shops curate what they accept and pay the original owner a share, so the selection skews newer and more brand-heavy.
Where can you sell designer clothes in Columbus?
Most shops in this guide accept consignments from the public, and buy-sell franchises like Plato’s Closet and Clothes Mentor pay cash on the spot for items they take. Terms differ shop to shop.
